Fatwa #691914 October 2002South Africa

While performing witr salat, I read a specific surah in the first and second rakah. Does the salaat have to be repeated? Can the same surah be recited in different rakah for any salaat?

Question

I realised the mistake after I had made takbir for dua-e-qunoot. Sajda Sahw was performed thereafter, as the mistake was realised. Does the salaat have to be repeated? Can the same surah be recited in different rakah for any salaat? Is this permitted?

Answer

It is undesirable to repeat a Surah in another Rakaat. However, that does not necessitate Sajdah-e-Sahw.

and Allah Ta'ala Knows Best

Mufti Ebrahim Desai

#5040Is one supposed to recite anything in Qiyam (Fatiha or Surahs following it) in Zuhr and Asar salaats behind the Imam?
#16709Not reciting Ta'awwudh (Aoudhubillah min-asshaytaan ir rajeem) in the first rakat of past salats
#15037A brother told me that we must recite the last three Surah of the Quran: Ikhlas,Falaq, Nas in the 3th rakat of Witr, Does this has a origin?
#47544He forgets to read a Surah in the first Rakah two Rakahs of Salah. Should he recite them in the third Rakah?
#66641)If I forget the Dua-Qunoot in the Witr, Is it valid or Sajda Sahw is necessary. 2) Maghrib Salaat. Instead of 3 rakaat he did 4 rakaat. upon realizing this mistake, he repeated Salaat again
#17526After reciting Surah Fathia but before starting Surah Ikhlaas during salat, is it necessary to say Bismillah?
#16293Which is more important in Esha salaat - the 2 rakaats Nafl before Witr or after Witr salaat?
#15873I need al proofs for raising the hands for the takbir of Qunut in Witr where the hands are raised like in Takbir al Tahrimah,

Something wrong with this record?

Question

Answer

Related rulings