Fatwa #307928 May 2001United Kingdom

Is it wajib to make up prayers if I did Makruh Tahrimun acts during them?

Question

I have been told that in the Hanafi madhab it is Wajib to make up prayers if a makruh tahrimun act was performed during it. Is this true? Also, how does the lay man distinguish between makruh tahrimun acts and makruh tanzilun acts, when books of Fiqh do not distinguish between them?

Answer

According to the Hanafi Madhab, when one unintentionally omits a Waajib act
and did not compensate it with Sajda-e-Sahw, the Salaat is
Makrooh-e-Tahrimi. It is Waajib to repeat such a Salaat within the Fardh
Salaat time.

and Allah Ta'ala Knows Best

Mufti Ebrahim Desai
FATWA DEPT.

#17650Praying bareheaded in the Hanafi madhab is Makruh. Is this Makruh Tanzihi or Makruh Tahrimi?
#16088I would like to ask what is the difference between halal, mustahab,mubah , wajib and sunnat. Also haram, makruhe tahrimi, makruh...etc. How to decide whether particular act is haram or makruh.
#14243I know in the Hanafi madhab niqab is wajib. However, many great Ulama such as Shaykh Nuh and Mufti Mahmud Ashraf 'Uthmani od Darul Ulum Karachi hold that in our times what is stressed more is the head scarf, due to the difficulty and ignorance of people in the west
#32539Adhering to one Madhab
#13438Now please Clarify whether as a hanafi, I can offer maghrib and Isha prayers together when ever i\’ll be travelling.
#9460u said that Hanafis cant club Maghrib and iSha prayers together if they are in a hurry or on a journey...refer bukhari hadiths Vol. 2 : No. 209
#8659siratul nu‘man or something. It says in that books that the hanifi madhab is influenced by early Persian law , is this true ?
#5481Fiqh masails for shafi in hanafi area

Something wrong with this record?

Question

Answer

Related rulings