Fatwa #134249 September 2005Mauritius

after Maghrib salaat with Jamaat that they will read the Esha Salaat in Jamaat immediately - due to Rainy weather conditions. Is that right

Question

Recently some salafi brothers Came up with a sahih hadith - and informed us after Maghrib salaat with Jamaat that they will read the Esha Salaat in Jamaat immediately - due to Rainy weather conditions. Is that right

Answer

According to the Hanafi Madhab it is incorrect to combine two Farz Salaah in one time except on the occasion of Haj. Therefore, one cannot combine the Maghrib and Esha Salaah in Maghrib time even though there is a valid excuse.

And Allah Knows Best

Mufti Ebrahim Desai

#10951Here at USA, I find people combining Salat Maghrib & Esha for Weather Conditions such as Raining. Is it permissible to combine salat in any fiqh?
#195391. Is it permissible to read the 2 rakaat sunnat after fardh namaaz? 2. Can one read fajr kazaa right until zohar salaat
#5589I once went for Salaat at a Masjid with a group and found that there is still lot of time left for the Jamaat. Since we were in a rush, I lead the prayer with the group with me. Is this not right?
#6803Why does an Imam read silently in Fardh Salaat for Zuhr and Asar, as oppposed to loudly for Fajr, Maghrib and Esha.
#16293Which is more important in Esha salaat - the 2 rakaats Nafl before Witr or after Witr salaat?
#16715Praying Maghrib salat immediately after the Azaan is against the well known ahadith of the Prophet?
#3438When can a person combine 2 salaats. I was at a course with people from Saudi Arabia & performed both their Zuhr and Asr salaat during the lunch break.
#2568Wudu broke during salaat in Jamaat ?

Something wrong with this record?

Question

Answer

Related rulings