Fatwa #912430 July 2003India

Is the hadith in question #8887 authentic?

Question

Is the hadith in question #8887 authentic? http://www.islam.tc/ask-imam/view.php?q=8887

Answer

Hafiz Haythami has mentioned that one of its narrators is weak. (Majma-uz-zawaaid vol.7 pg.119)

According to the principles laid by the Muhadditheen, this Hadith is acceptable.

and Allah Ta'ala Knows Best

Mufti Ebrahim Desai

#3321Would you please comment on the authenticities of the following hadiths, if they are sahih or hasan, who rated or classifed them, and if they are abrogating to other similar hadith.
#16635How do we know hadiths are authentic and not corrupted because i have met people who do not believe in Hadiths at all?
#18332What is the correct sunnah when the child is born? Should the azaan and iqaamah both be given in the right and left ears respectively or only the azaan should be given because the hadith of Hasan bin Ali and Ibn Abbas (RA) is weak and the hadith of Abu Raafi' is authentic? Why is the azaan and iqaamah both encouraged when the ahaadeeth are weak rather, only the azaan should be encouraged because of the authenticity of the hadith. Please clarify.
#9323"Difference of opinion in my Community is a mercy for people". Is this hadith authentic?
#16593Authenticity of this Hadith
#46533Is the Hadith of Salat At-Tasbih authentic?
#40869Is this hadith authentic? Is celibacy allowed in Islam?
#46181Is this Hadith authentic?

Something wrong with this record?

Question

Answer

Related rulings