Fatwa #300522 May 2001United States of America

Has Shaikh Zakariya(RAH) included fabircared ahadith in Fadhaile amaal.

Question

There is a hadith quoted by Shaikh Zakariya (RAH) in fadhaile aamaal in Neglect of salah about the 15 punishments for neglect of salah. Is this hadith.MAUZOO (Fabricated hadith). If so then why is it in Fadhaaile amaal.

Answer

There are no fabricated Ahaadith in Fadhaail-e-Aamaal of Hadhrat Shaykh
Zakariyya (RA). Hadhrat Shaykh was an authority in Hadith.

and Allah Ta'ala Knows Best

Mufti Ebrahim Desai
FATWA DEPT.

#9158confused. question (Q3005) deals with whether Fazail-Amaal contains fabricated hadith. (Q9044) deals with a Hadith that is in Fazail-e-Amaal - questioner is warned from quoting fabricated ahadith
#13128Fabricated Ahadith in Fazail Amaal
#10963Why fabrication in ahadiths??
#27892Is it correct to call Mawlana Muhammad Zakariya a Muhaddith even though he mentions fabricated stories in his books?
#46849Are the Aḥādīth in Maulānā Zakariya's books problematic?
#5291Fazail-e-amal. if u read same hadith on same pg in arabic u will find a word MAWDU' which we know means fabricated. The same is not translated into english or Urdu. That is a clear lie on the Prophet
#13306Concerning the fabricated hadiths of Fadhaail-e-Aamaal
#15951Faza'il Amaal and Daeef Hadith

Something wrong with this record?

Question

Answer

Related rulings