Fatwa #134821 October 2000Pakistan

I thought Muslims aren't allowed to judge? In this site, it clearly says Imam Komeni was not a Muslim - why judge when Allah is the only one to judge?

Question

How can someone say that a shia is not muslim. Nobody except Allah (SWT) knows anyones intention when they are dying and when they will face their lord. (I am referring to Imam Komeni - you said that he was not a Muslim). Only Allah is to judge who is Muslim or not.

Answer

Almighty Allah Ta'ala Himself has given us the Shari'ah as a criteria to
determine the right from wrong. Therefore, we are obliged to judge according
to the criteria set out by Allah Himself.

and Allah Ta'ala Knows Best

Mufti Ebrahim Desai
FATWA DEPT.

#53921) is their claim valid? Please provide justification of AbuBakar(RA), Omar(RA), Utman(RA) being the 1st,2nd and 3rd kholifa of islam. 2) Imam Abu Hanifa (RA) studied under their Imam Jafar??
#19118What are the questions that will be asked in the grave? Can one follow the ideologies of the Shias?
#18704My question in regards to nikah. I am a sunni (hanafi) and my wife to be is a shia (twelver imami). Is there a difference in conducting the nikah when it comes to the two different schools of thought? ..
#35517Shias and Hadhrat Muawiyah Radhiyallahu Anhu
#29565Is our Imam Mahdi the same person the Shias refer to as Imam Mahdi?
#5469Why aren't woman allowed into a graveyard? And is it true that the dead see woman naked and unclothed?
#31017What are our beliefs concerning the twelve Shia Imams?
#14708We pray Jumaa in the university. The Imam is from Ahl-e-Hadith and he gives Khutba in english whereas I heard in one of Maulana Taqi Usmani's lectures that it is compulsory to give Khutba in Arabic. When I told our Imam, he told me of a Syrian mufti who allowed him to do so.

Something wrong with this record?

Question

Answer

Related rulings